Wikisage, the free encyclopedia of the second generation, is digital heritage

Pali Canon: Difference between revisions

From Wikisage
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
(27 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The '''Pali Canon''' is the scripture collection of Theravada Buddhism.<ref>Gethin, ''Sayings of the Buddha'', Oxford World Classics, 2008, page xiii</ref> "Pali Canon" is the usual English name;<ref>Gombrich, foreword to Pali Text Society edition of Geiger, ''Pali Grammar''; there are typographical variants: Pali/Pāli/Pāḷi Canon/canon</ref> it is also known by the name "Tipiṭaka".<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Budhism'', Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed, 2012, page 459</ref> It is in Pali,<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Budhism'', Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page 3</ref> which is a language of ancient India.<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Budhism'', Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page xx</ref> Mahayana Buddhism tends to regards the Tipiṭaka as a sort of "[[Old Testament]]"<ref>''Encyclopaedia Britannica'', 2002 printing, volume 11, page 791 (article Tipitaka)</ref>. Most scholars recognize the Canon as the oldest source for the Buddha's teachings.<ref>Mousa, ''World Religions Demystified'', McGraw-Hill, 2014, page 35; Schopen, ''Bones, Stones, and Buddhist Monks'', University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu, 1997, pages 23f / reprinted from ''Studien zur Indologie und Iranistik'', volume 10 (1985), page 9 / also quoted in "The Historical Authenticity of Early Buddhist Literature: A Critical Evaluation", ''Vienna Journal of South Asian Studies'', Vol XLIX (2005)/[http://www.ocbs.org/images/stories/awynne2005wzks.pdf], page 37</ref>  
The '''Pali Canon''' is the scripture collection of Theravada Buddhism.<ref>Gethin, ''Sayings of the Buddha'', Oxford World Classics, 2008, page xiii</ref> "Pali Canon" is the usual English name;<ref>Gombrich, foreword to Pali Text Society edition of Geiger, ''Pali Grammar''; there are typographical variants: Pali/Pāli/Pāḷi Canon/canon</ref> it is also known by the name "Tipiṭaka".<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Buddhism'', Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed, 2012, page 459</ref> It is in Pali,<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Buddhism'', Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page 3</ref> which is a language of ancient India.<ref>Harvey, ''Introduction to Buddhism'', Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page xx</ref> Mahayana Buddhism tends to regards the Tipiṭaka as a sort of "[[Old Testament]]"<ref>''Encyclopaedia Britannica'', 2002 printing, volume 11, page 791 (article Tipitaka)</ref>. Most scholars recognize the Canon as the oldest source for the Buddha's teachings.<ref>Mousa, ''World Religions Demystified'', McGraw-Hill, 2014, page 35; Schopen, ''Bones, Stones, and Buddhist Monks'', University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu, 1997, pages 23f / reprinted from ''Studien zur Indologie und Iranistik'', volume 10 (1985), page 9 / also quoted in "The historical authenticity of early Buddhist literature: a critical evaluation", ''Vienna Journal of South Asian Studies'', Vol XLIX (2005)/[https://ocbs.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/awynne2005wzks.pdf], page 37</ref>


==Background==
==Background==
Line 13: Line 13:
==Table of contents==
==Table of contents==


English titles are taken from the Pali Text Society: titles of translations published by them, except for 3 books they haven't yet translated.
English titles are taken from the Pali Text Society: titles of translations published by them, except for 2 books they haven't yet translated.


*Vinaya Pitaka (Book of the discipline)
*Vinaya Pitaka (Book of the discipline)
Line 21: Line 21:
**Samyutta Nikaya (Connected discourses of the Buddha)
**Samyutta Nikaya (Connected discourses of the Buddha)
**Anguttara Nikaya (Numerical discourses of the Buddha)
**Anguttara Nikaya (Numerical discourses of the Buddha)
**Khuddaka Nikaya: as can be seen from the external links below, the contents of this section vary between editions, with some including all the following but others omitting some
**Khuddaka Nikaya: the contents of this section vary between editions, with some including all the following but others omitting one or more ([https://web.archive.org/web/20120820132850/http://society.worldtipitaka.info/world-tipitaka-project/world-tipitaka-roman-script/comparative-tipitaka-volumes]); Professor Norman, sometime President of the Pali Text Society, asks how one is supposed to tell whether books included in printed editions are regarded as canonical.<ref>''Philological Approach to Buddhism'', School of Oriental and African Studies, London, 1997, page 141; also quoted by Oliver Freiberger in ''Kanonisierung und Kanonbildung in der asiatischen Religionsgeschichte'', ed Max Deeg et al, Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Vienna, 2011, page 218</ref>
***Khuddakapatha (Minor readings)
***Khuddakapatha (Minor readings)
***Dhammapada (Word of the doctrine)
***Dhammapada (Word of the doctrine)
Line 31: Line 31:
***Theragatha (Poems of early Buddhist monks)
***Theragatha (Poems of early Buddhist monks)
***Therigatha (Poems of early Buddhist nuns)
***Therigatha (Poems of early Buddhist nuns)
***Apadana (Legends<ref>"Illustrator of ultimate meaning" (in 1 volume with "Minor readings"), page 2</ref>)
***Buddhavamsa (Chronicle of Buddhas)
***Cariyapitaka (Basket of conduct)
***Jataka (Stories of the Buddha's former births)
***Jataka (Stories of the Buddha's former births)
***Niddesa (Book of demonstration<ref>"Illustrator of ultimate meaning" (in 1 volume with "Minor readings"), page 2</ref>)
***Niddesa (Exposition<ref>Suttanipata translation, page 18</ref>)
****Maha Niddesa
****Maha Niddesa
****Culla or Cula Niddesa
****Culla or Cula Niddesa
***Patisambhidamagga (Path of discrimination)
***Patisambhidamagga (Path of discrimination)
***Apadana (Legends<ref>"Illustrator of ultimate meaning" (in 1 volume with "Minor readings"), page 2</ref>)
***Buddhavamsa (Chronicle of Buddhas)
***Cariyapitaka (Basket of conduct)
***Netti (The guide)
***Netti (The guide)
***Petakopadesa (Piṭaka-disclosure)  
***Petakopadesa (Piṭaka-disclosure)  
Line 48: Line 48:
**Puggalapannatti (Designation of human types)
**Puggalapannatti (Designation of human types)
**Kathavatthu (Points of controversy)
**Kathavatthu (Points of controversy)
**Yamaka (Book of pairs<ref>''Abhidhammatthasa&#7749;gaha & Abhidhammatthavibhāvinī-ṭīkā'', page xiii</ref>)
**Yamaka (Book of pairs)
**Patthana (Conditional relations)
**Patthana (Conditional relations)


==Where next? External links and further reading==
==Where next?==


*[https://web.archive.org/web/20120820132850/http://society.worldtipitaka.info/world-tipitaka-project/world-tipitaka-roman-script/comparative-tipitaka-volumes Parallel volume-by-volume table of contents of a number of editions]; see [https://web.archive.org/web/20120722154929/http://society.worldtipitaka.info/world-tipitaka-project/world-tipitaka-roman-script/reference-to-pali-tipitaka-editions-in-various-scripts] for the code letters used there.
* Detailed outlines (from shortest to longest)
* Detailed outlines (from shortest to longest)
** ''An Analysis of the Pāli Canon'', edited by Russell Webb, Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Sri Lanka, 3rd edition, 2008; [http://www.bps.lk/olib/wh/wh217-u.html]; includes extensive bibliography
** ''An Analysis of the Pāli Canon'', edited by Russell Webb, Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Sri Lanka, 3rd edition, 2008; online at [http://www.bps.lk/olib/wh/wh217_Webb_Analysis-of-the-Pali-Canon.html]; includes extensive bibliography
** ''An Outline Of the Pāḷi Canon'', compiled from various sources by Allan R. Bomhard, Charleston Buddhist Fellowship, Charleston, SC USA, 2013 (2557); online at [https://www.academia.edu/38036561/An_Outline_Of_the_P%C4%81li_Canon?email_work_card=title]
** ''Guide to Tipiṭaka'', compiled by U Ko Lay, Burma Piṭaka Association, Rangoon, 1986; reprinted in India, Malaysia, Taiwan and Thailand; now online at numerous websites, e.g. [http://www.buddhanet.net/pdf_file/tipitaka.pdf], [http://www.archive.org/details/guidetotipitaka029042mbp], [http://www.archive.org/stream/guidetotipitaka029042mbp#page/n1/mode/2up], [http://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/guide-to-tipitaka/d/doc3409.html]
** ''Guide to Tipiṭaka'', compiled by U Ko Lay, Burma Piṭaka Association, Rangoon, 1986; reprinted in India, Malaysia, Taiwan and Thailand; now online at numerous websites, e.g. [http://www.buddhanet.net/pdf_file/tipitaka.pdf], [http://www.archive.org/details/guidetotipitaka029042mbp], [http://www.archive.org/stream/guidetotipitaka029042mbp#page/n1/mode/2up], [http://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/guide-to-tipitaka/d/doc3409.html]
** ''A History of Pāli Literature'', by Bimala Churn Law, volume I, Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner, London, 1933; [http://tera-3.ul.cs.cmu.edu/cgi-bin/reader.pl?call=35453]
** ''A History of Pali Literature'' by Bimala Churn Law, originally published in 2 volumes in 1933 (Volume I on the Canon), reprinted in 1 volume, online at [http://www.academia.edu/4088767/A_History_of_Pali_Literature_by_Bimala_Churn_Law]
** ''New Guide to the Tipitaka. A Complete Reference to the Pâli Buddhist Canon'', Matthew Meghaprasara, Sangha of Books, Delhi, 2013; [http://www.amazon.com/New-Guide-Tipitaka-Complete-Reference/dp/1926892682 Amazon]
* ''The Lion's Roar: an Anthology of the Buddha's Teachings Selected from the Pāḷi Canon'', David Maurice, Rider, London, 1962; American printing Citadel, New York, 1967: online at [http://www.kbrl.gov.mm/book/download/002593]; this seems to be the only anthology including selections from all three pitakas; it also represents all five nikayas, but not all the individual books listed above
* Anthologies in English
* [http://www.palitext.com/ The Pali Text Society] publishes Pali texts, translations, an ''Introduction to Pali'', a ''Pali-English Dictionary'', etc.; if some of the tabs at the top of the home page don't work on your computer, click on Sitemap at left
** Selections from all three pitakas
***''The Lion's Roar: an Anthology of the Buddha's Teachings Selected from the Pāḷi Canon'', David Maurice, Rider, London, 1962; American printing Citadel, New York, 1967; online at [http://www.kbrl.gov.mm/book/download/002593]
** Selections from the first two pitakas
***''Some Sayings of the Buddha According to the Pali Canon'', translated by F.L. Woodward, Oxford World Classics, 1924; reprinted Buddhist Society, London, 1974; online at [http://www.kbrl.gov.mm/book/download/001197]
***''The Life of Gotama the Buddha, Compiled Exclusively from the Pali Canon'' by E. H. Brewster, Kegan, Paul, Trench, Trubner, London, 1926
***''The Life of the Buddha As It Appears in the Pali Canon, the Oldest Authentic Record'', translation from the Pali, selection of material, and arrangement, by Bhikkhu Ñ&#257;ṇamoli, [[Buddhist Publication Society]], Kandy, Sri Lanka, 1972: [http://www.bps.lk/bookshop-search.php?styp=lst&&s=1&d=bp101s]
**Selections from the last two pitakas
***''Buddhist Meditation: an Anthology of Texts from the Pali Canon'', Sarah Shaw, Routledge, London / New York, 2006: [http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9780415485685/]
**Selections from all five nikayas
***''The Word of the Buddha: an Outline of the Teachings of the Buddha in the Words of the Pali Canon'', compiled, translated, and explained by Nyanatiloka, Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Ceylon, 1935: [http://www.enabling.org/ia/vipassana/Archive/N/Nyanatiloka/WOB/]
***''Wings to Awakening: an Anthology from the Pali Canon'', by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, 6th revised edition, 2011: [http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/thanissaro/wings/index.html]
**Selections from the first four nikayas
***Teachings of the Buddha: ''In the Buddha's Words: an Anthology of Discourses from the Pali Canon'', edited and introduced by Bhikkhu Bodhi, Wisdom Publications, Somerville, Mass., 2005: [http://www.wisdompubs.org/book/buddhas-words]
* [http://www.palitext.com/ The Pali Text Society] publishes Pali texts (including the Canon), translations (including most of the Canon), an ''Introduction to Pali'', a ''Pali-English Dictionary'', etc.; if some of the tabs at the top of the home page don't work on your browser, click on Sitemap at left
*Complete text (in Pali)
*Complete text (in Pali)
**image files
**image files
***''Braḥ Traipiṭakapāḷi'', 110 volumes, Phnom Penh, 1931-1969:[https://web.archive.org/web/20120606015925/http://dhamma4khmer2.org/Tipitaka_Reading_1.html]
***''Braḥ Traipiṭakapāḷi'', 110 volumes, Phnom Penh, 1931-1969: [https://web.archive.org/web/20120606015925/http://dhamma4khmer2.org/Tipitaka_Reading_1.html]
***''Buddhajayanti Tripitaka'', 52 volumes [in 58], published under the patronage of (the government of) Ceylon/Sri Lanka, 1957-1989: [http://www.pali-text-images.net/bjt/index.htm]
***''Buddhajayanti Tripitaka'', 52 volumes [in 58], published under the patronage of the government of Ceylon/Sri Lanka, 1957-1989:  
***''Chaṭṭhasa&#7749;gītipiṭaka&#x1E41;'', Ministry of Religious Affairs, Yangon [Rangoon], 2008, 40 volumes: [http://www.btmar.org/content/tipitaka-del-sexto-concilio-buddhista-textos-pali]; complete set, including commentaries and subcommentaries, can be downloaded free of charge from [http://www.btmar.org/content/tipitaka-del-sexto-concilio-buddhista-inicio]
****[http://www.pali-text-images.net/bjt/index.htm]
***another edition of this (or different volumes from different editions): [http://www.pali-text-images.net/cst/index.htm]  
****[http://www.aathaapi.net/tipitaka/]
***and another: [http://www.kbrl.gov.mm/catalog/Index/39?page=32] (click on Eng to get the page in English instead of Burmese); also includes English translations of a lot of the Canon
***''Chaṭṭhasa&#7749;gītipiṭaka&#x1E41;'', 40 volumes; various printings:
****Ministry of Religious Affairs, Yangon, 2008: [https://web.archive.org/web/20190627171205/http://www.btmar.org/content/tipitaka-del-sexto-concilio-buddhista-textos-pali]
****[http://www.pali-text-images.net/cst/index.htm]  
****[http://www.kbrl.gov.mm/catalog/Index/39?page=32] (click on Eng to get the page in English instead of Burmese); also includes English translations of a lot of the Canon
**text files
**text files
***Sri Lanka Tripitaka Project: [http://web.archive.org/web/20100615203958/http://buddhistethics.org/palicanon.html]; also includes many other Pali texts
***Sri Lanka Tripitaka Project: [http://web.archive.org/web/20100615203958/http://buddhistethics.org/palicanon.html]; also includes many other Pali texts
Line 85: Line 76:
***Vipassana Research Institute, Igatpuri, India: [http://www.tipitaka.org]; also includes commentaries, subcommentaries and other Pali texts  
***Vipassana Research Institute, Igatpuri, India: [http://www.tipitaka.org]; also includes commentaries, subcommentaries and other Pali texts  
**watch  this space:
**watch  this space:
***[http://sydney.edu.au/arts/research/kuthodaw/]
***[https://www.pali-text-images.net/]: site provider hopes to add more editions
***[http://www.budsir.org] has carried an under construction notice for many months
***[http://www.budsir.org] has carried an under construction notice for many months
*[https://sites.google.com/a/worldtipitaka.info/society/world-tipitaka-project/world-tipitaka-roman-script/comparative-tipitaka-volumes Parallel volume-by-volume table of contents of a number of editions]; see [https://sites.google.com/a/worldtipitaka.info/society/world-tipitaka-project/world-tipitaka-roman-script/reference-to-pali-tipitaka-editions-in-various-scripts] for the code letters used there.
***[https://opencontext.org/projects/b6de18c6-bba8-4b53-9d9e-3eea4b794268]
*Buddhaghosa's Visuddhimagga (probably 5th century AD) has been described as a "general commentary to the whole canon"<ref>''Dispeller of Delusion'', volume I, Pali Text Society, 1987, page vii</ref>
**''The Path of Purity'', translated by Pe Maung Tin, [3 volumes,] [1922]-1931; reprinted in 1 volume, Pali Text Society
**''The Path of Purification'', translated by Bhikkhu Ñāṇamoli, 1956; reprint Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Sri Lanka


==Notes==
==Notes==


<references/>
<references/>

Revision as of 09:59, 18 October 2019

The Pali Canon is the scripture collection of Theravada Buddhism.[1] "Pali Canon" is the usual English name;[2] it is also known by the name "Tipiṭaka".[3] It is in Pali,[4] which is a language of ancient India.[5] Mahayana Buddhism tends to regards the Tipiṭaka as a sort of "Old Testament"[6]. Most scholars recognize the Canon as the oldest source for the Buddha's teachings.[7]

Background

The Canon is traditionally regarded by the Theravada as the Word of the Buddha (died around 400 BC[8]), though not always literally.[9] It is said in the Canon itself that whatever is well said is the Word of the Buddha.[10] Modern scholars tend to regard at least large amounts of the Canon (with disagreements on how much) as the work of a number of unknown authors ([2]).

According to a tradition generally regarded quite favourably by scholars, the Canon was written down from oral tradition in Ceylon (Sri Lanka) in the last century BC.[11] The oldest known manuscript fragment of the Canon dates from the 8th or 9th century, but in general manuscripts have not survived from before the 15th century, and the majority are probably no older than the 18th.[12]

The Canon has now been printed and posted on the internet: see links below.

The vast majority of commentarial literature is connected with just four names: Buddhaghosa, Dhammapala, Sariputta and Nanakitti.[13]

Table of contents

English titles are taken from the Pali Text Society: titles of translations published by them, except for 2 books they haven't yet translated.

  • Vinaya Pitaka (Book of the discipline)
  • Sutta or Suttanta Pitaka
    • Digha Nikaya (Dialogues of the Buddha)
    • Majjhima Nikaya (Middle length discourses of the Buddha)
    • Samyutta Nikaya (Connected discourses of the Buddha)
    • Anguttara Nikaya (Numerical discourses of the Buddha)
    • Khuddaka Nikaya: the contents of this section vary between editions, with some including all the following but others omitting one or more ([3]); Professor Norman, sometime President of the Pali Text Society, asks how one is supposed to tell whether books included in printed editions are regarded as canonical.[14]
      • Khuddakapatha (Minor readings)
      • Dhammapada (Word of the doctrine)
      • Udana (Verses of uplift)
      • Itivuttaka (As it was said)
      • Suttanipata (Group of discourses)
      • Vimanavatthu (Stories of the mansions)
      • Petavatthu (Stories of the departed)
      • Theragatha (Poems of early Buddhist monks)
      • Therigatha (Poems of early Buddhist nuns)
      • Apadana (Legends[15])
      • Buddhavamsa (Chronicle of Buddhas)
      • Cariyapitaka (Basket of conduct)
      • Jataka (Stories of the Buddha's former births)
      • Niddesa (Exposition[16])
        • Maha Niddesa
        • Culla or Cula Niddesa
      • Patisambhidamagga (Path of discrimination)
      • Netti (The guide)
      • Petakopadesa (Piṭaka-disclosure)
      • Milindapanha (Milinda's questions)
  • Abhidhamma Pitaka
    • Dhammasangani (A Buddhist manual of psychological ethics)
    • Vibhanga (Book of analysis)
    • Dhatukatha (Discourse on elements)
    • Puggalapannatti (Designation of human types)
    • Kathavatthu (Points of controversy)
    • Yamaka (Book of pairs)
    • Patthana (Conditional relations)

Where next?

  • Parallel volume-by-volume table of contents of a number of editions; see [4] for the code letters used there.
  • Detailed outlines (from shortest to longest)
    • An Analysis of the Pāli Canon, edited by Russell Webb, Buddhist Publication Society, Kandy, Sri Lanka, 3rd edition, 2008; online at [5]; includes extensive bibliography
    • An Outline Of the Pāḷi Canon, compiled from various sources by Allan R. Bomhard, Charleston Buddhist Fellowship, Charleston, SC USA, 2013 (2557); online at [6]
    • Guide to Tipiṭaka, compiled by U Ko Lay, Burma Piṭaka Association, Rangoon, 1986; reprinted in India, Malaysia, Taiwan and Thailand; now online at numerous websites, e.g. [7], [8], [9], [10]
    • A History of Pali Literature by Bimala Churn Law, originally published in 2 volumes in 1933 (Volume I on the Canon), reprinted in 1 volume, online at [11]
  • The Lion's Roar: an Anthology of the Buddha's Teachings Selected from the Pāḷi Canon, David Maurice, Rider, London, 1962; American printing Citadel, New York, 1967: online at [12]; this seems to be the only anthology including selections from all three pitakas; it also represents all five nikayas, but not all the individual books listed above
  • The Pali Text Society publishes Pali texts, translations, an Introduction to Pali, a Pali-English Dictionary, etc.; if some of the tabs at the top of the home page don't work on your computer, click on Sitemap at left
  • Complete text (in Pali)
    • image files
      • Braḥ Traipiṭakapāḷi, 110 volumes, Phnom Penh, 1931-1969: [13]
      • Buddhajayanti Tripitaka, 52 volumes [in 58], published under the patronage of the government of Ceylon/Sri Lanka, 1957-1989:
      • Chaṭṭhasaṅgītipiṭakaṁ, 40 volumes; various printings:
        • Ministry of Religious Affairs, Yangon, 2008: [16]
        • [17]
        • [18] (click on Eng to get the page in English instead of Burmese); also includes English translations of a lot of the Canon
    • text files
      • Sri Lanka Tripitaka Project: [19]; also includes many other Pali texts
      • Sutta Central: [20]; see [21], [22] for background on this; also includes early Buddhist literature in other languages
      • Vipassana Research Institute, Igatpuri, India: [23]; also includes commentaries, subcommentaries and other Pali texts
    • watch this space:
      • [24]: site provider hopes to add more editions
      • [25] has carried an under construction notice for many months
      • [26]

Notes

  1. Gethin, Sayings of the Buddha, Oxford World Classics, 2008, page xiii
  2. Gombrich, foreword to Pali Text Society edition of Geiger, Pali Grammar; there are typographical variants: Pali/Pāli/Pāḷi Canon/canon
  3. Harvey, Introduction to Buddhism, Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed, 2012, page 459
  4. Harvey, Introduction to Buddhism, Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page 3
  5. Harvey, Introduction to Buddhism, Cambridge University Press, 1st ed, 1990, page xx
  6. Encyclopaedia Britannica, 2002 printing, volume 11, page 791 (article Tipitaka)
  7. Mousa, World Religions Demystified, McGraw-Hill, 2014, page 35; Schopen, Bones, Stones, and Buddhist Monks, University of Hawai'i Press, Honolulu, 1997, pages 23f / reprinted from Studien zur Indologie und Iranistik, volume 10 (1985), page 9 / also quoted in "The historical authenticity of early Buddhist literature: a critical evaluation", Vienna Journal of South Asian Studies, Vol XLIX (2005)/[1], page 37
  8. consensus of scholars: Gethin, Sayings of the Buddha, Oxford World Classics, 2008, page xv
  9. Gombrich, Theravada Buddhism, Routledge, London, 1st edn, 1988 / 2nd edn, 2006, page 20
  10. The Numerical Discourses of the Buddha, Wisdom Publications / Pali Text Society, page 1120; Gradual Sayings, Pali Text Society, volume IV, page 112
  11. Gethin, Buddhist Path to Awakening, Brill, Leiden / New York / Köln, 1992, page 8
  12. Gethin, Sayings of the Buddha, Oxford University Press, pages xxiif
  13. Journal of the Pali Text Society, volume XXVI, page 134
  14. Philological Approach to Buddhism, School of Oriental and African Studies, London, 1997, page 141; also quoted by Oliver Freiberger in Kanonisierung und Kanonbildung in der asiatischen Religionsgeschichte, ed Max Deeg et al, Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Vienna, 2011, page 218
  15. "Illustrator of ultimate meaning" (in 1 volume with "Minor readings"), page 2
  16. Suttanipata translation, page 18